Breaking News
Editorials

Transparency: Court made wrong decision on meetings

2 min read
(Editorial - Graphic Illustration - MetroCreativeConnection)

Three West Virginia Supreme Court justices got it wrong this week when they ruled the state's college government boards can meet behind closed doors to discuss their budgets, student tuition and even details as mundane as how they believe their school's sports teams will fare in the upcoming season.

On the other hand, the two dissenting justices -- Charles Trump and James Flanigan -- understood the mistake being made when taxpayer-funded entities are given license to conduct their business in the dark.

"The public is entitled to observe how the board determines the expenditure of these substantial public funds," Trump wrote.

Justice H.L. Kirkpatrick, along with Chief Justice Haley Bunn and Justice William Wooton decided nearly all the topics discussed during West Virginia University Board of Governors meetings back in 2020 warranted going into executive session, claiming they believe most of the topics were a matter of "commercial competition," and therefore none of taxpayers' business.

In his dissent, Trump correctly wrote that such a decision allows "a substantial portion of the ordinary business of every public college or university" to be kept secret from the people paying for it.

This wasn't just a once or twice event, by the way, the case made by HD Media Company LLC (owner of the Charleston Gazette-Mail) focused on FIVE meetings in the summer and fall of 2020.

Surely justices understand the slippery slope down which they just pushed these government bodies.

"Nearly every significant decision made by a public university or college can affect its financial interests in some way," Trump wrote.

Why increase the opportunity for more of that business to take place in the shadows? Those in the majority on this decision have accomplished little more than encouraging others conducting public meetings to behave badly. That, in turn, will send more work the Supreme Court's way. We can hope only that they get it right next time.

Starting at /week.