Breaking News
Editorials

Labor Force: Sobering numbers should drive change

3 min read
(Editorial - Graphic Illustration - MetroCreativeConnection)

West Virginia has historically been at or very near the bottom for workforce participation rates, as compared with the rest of the country. A group of state lawmakers finally wants to do something about that. No, not by figuring out how to get more of those who can work into a job. They want to change the way the rate is calculated.

Members of the Legislative Oversight Commission on Workforce Development and Labor discussed the matter Tuesday. Monthly numbers released by the St. Louis Federal Reserve show West Virginia's labor force participation rate was 54.7% in July, second only to Mississippi with 54.4%.

We can make that comparison because every state's rate is calculated using federal standards. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics says the rate measures the civilian noninstitutional population age 16 and older.

" … We could not figure out, I think, as a state for years, maybe decades, how come we're at the bottom? This looks awful and sounds awful," said Commission Co-Chair Roland Roberts, R-Raleigh.

Of course it does. And it's not difficult to figure out where anyone working in Charleston these days got the idea that if you don't like the way a number looks, you change the way it gets calculated.

We are one of the oldest, unhealthiest states in the country. Roberts is right, there are a significant number of people here who would not be able to fill most traditional jobs.

"When you take out the folks who are older than 75 and you take out the folks who are disabled and couldn't work, it took our labor force participation rate to almost 75%, which is huge," WorkForce West Virginia Director Scott Adkins said.

Unless the federal standard changes, making such an adjustment would be, as State Sen. Mike Caputo, D-Marion, put it "kind of deceiving."

What if, instead, we addressed the problems of how many are aging out of our workforce without an equal number of younger workers growing up and staying here to replace them? What if we worked harder to keep our communities healthier?

"As far as workforce participation, I'm concerned we're going to educate these kids to go work in other states. I think we need to stop that flow," Roberts said.

It's a valid concern, and one that should spur changes that inspires young people to stay and work here. Lying to them about the numbers is a sure way to do the opposite.

Starting at /week.