West Virginia Supreme Court rules Tourism Development District Act constitutional
Trending
CHARLESTON - A near-unanimous decision by the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals recently clears the way for a state tourism incentive program narrowly tailored for a long-delayed hotel project in Harpers Ferry.
In a 4-1 decision released Friday with Judge D. Andrew McMunn sitting in place of Justice Charles Trump, who recused himself, the state Supreme Court affirmed the decisions of the Intermediate Court of Appeals and a Kanawha County Circuit Court judge, holding that the Tourism Development District Act is constitutional.
The petitioners, a group of citizens from Harpers Ferry, challenged the act, passed in 2020, on the grounds that it represented unconstitutional special legislation, violated equal protection guarantees and stripped residents of their constitutional rights to local self-rule and voting power by exempting major tourism developments from municipal oversight.
The Tourism Development District Act gives the state Development Office authority to involve itself in tourism projects that qualify for the tourism tax credits in historic districts and have a minimum private investment of $25 million in Class IV municipalities, which are cities with 2,000 or fewer residents.
Once designated, a tourism development district is exempted from municipal regulatory authority - including zoning, land use, historic preservation, building permits, noise, lighting and licensing ordinances - and placed under state-level regulatory oversight. The bill was specifically aimed at the Hill Top House project in Harpers Ferry but could apply to as many as five projects that qualify for tax credits under the Tourism Development Act.
Writing for the majority, Justice William Wooton said that the Tourism Development District Act does not target specific people or entities, nor does it establish one project to the detriment of others. It applies statewide to a broad class of hundreds of small municipalities.
"After reviewing the Act, we reject the petitioners' argument," Wooton wrote. "The Act merely encourages tourism development projects in small municipalities by granting benefits to up to five large projects that private entities want to locate in small communities. The petitioners have pointed to nothing specific to indicate the classifications are capricious, unreasonable, or arbitrary. Accordingly, we find no error by the ICA or the circuit court in their conclusions that the Act does not violate the special law prohibitions of the Constitution."
Wooton also dismissed the arguments made by the Harpers Ferry residents that the act violated equal protection provisions in the Constitution or the autonomy of municipalities, which are considered subdivisions of the state.
"The circuit court and the ICA found no inherent right to 'self-rule' in the text of the West Virginia Constitution, and no case creating such a right. In fact, the opposite is true," Wooton wrote. "Moreover, the Act does nothing to contravene the petitioners' right to participate in any election. The Act merely modifies powers previously granted to small municipalities with no impact on the municipalities' residents' right to vote. Whether the Legislature chooses to delegate powers to municipalities or decides to withdraw them ... are generally not subject to judicial review."
Chief Justice C. Haley Bunn dissented from the majority’s decision, focusing on procedural and jurisdictional deficiencies rather than the constitutional merits of the case. She argued that the Supreme Court should have remanded the case to the circuit court to develop factual findings regarding whether petitioners suffered an injury, allowing them to bring a case or order a supplemental briefing on standing prior to ruling on the merits.
"... Neither party addressed the issue in its briefing to this Court," Bunn wrote. "The majority opinion leapfrogs over this necessary inquiry, proceeding directly to address the substantive issues on appeal. I would have remanded this case back to the circuit court for further findings of fact about the Petitioners' standing and the court's resulting jurisdiction, or, at the very least, ordered the parties to submit additional briefing regarding the issue."
A group of investors - SWaN Hill Top House Hotel LLC - has been wanting to renovate the dilapidated 129-room historic hotel in Harpers Ferry, but the project has been held up for one reason or another for nearly 20 years due to issues with the Harpers Ferry government and local residents.
The property was acquired by SWaN in 2007. The Department of Economic Development approved SWaN’s application in 2021, designating the Hill Top project as an approved tourism development district. The SWaN private investment was estimated at the time at $138 million.
The Hill Top House was built in the late 19th century by Black entrepreneur Thomas Lovett. During its history, the hotel played host to famous guests such as President Calvin Coolidge, telephone inventor Alexander Graham Bell, author Mark Twain and civil rights leader W.E.B. Du Bois.
The hotel site continues to deteriorate, according to the Harpers Ferry Historic Landmarks Commission. The Journal reported in June that the commission wrote a letter to the state Department of Commerce raising concerns about the lack of progress by SWaN, which began demolishing Hill Top House in 2021.