Breaking News
Local News

Warner calls for uniformity in primary elections

By Jess Mancini 4 min read
Mike Pushkin, left, Kris Warner, right

PARKERSBURG - The secretary of state of West Virginia is calling for uniformity in primary elections.

"By most measures, this midterm election was excellent from an election integrity standpoint. However, no election is perfect, and there is always room for improvement,” Secretary of State Kris Warner said.

“From an administrative standpoint, two of the greatest issues across the state were low voter turnout and the lack of uniformity between the two major parties’ primary elections," he said. "It is possible that the two are related.”

The primary election in May was the first in decades that the Republican Party closed the election to unaffiliated voters while the Democratic Party primary remained open to independents. West Virginia is among only eight states allowing unaffiliated voters to participate in one major party’s primary, but not the other, Warner said.

“There is a basic principle in elections that the same rules must be fairly applied to everybody. So when we see not one, but two legal challenges filed as a result of inconsistent standards, it’s a major red flag,” Warner said. “It might work in the minority of states with semi-closed primaries, but we have real-world examples from this year showing that it did not work in West Virginia.”

In Fayette County after the primary, a candidate for the Republican Executive Committee filed a challenge based on allegations of unaffiliated voters participating in the Republican Primary, Warner said. Based on the evidence, that election was overturned and was ordered to be on the ballot of the general election, Warner said.

In Harrison County, a legislative candidate filed a similar challenge, but was resolved without ordering a new election, he said.

"Objectively, it is clear that a lack of uniformity between political party primaries hurts election integrity," Warner said. "Not only did we see legal challenges based on inconsistent applications of the closed primary rules, but turnout in the 2026 elections was the lowest in over a decade. I suspect that the lack of uniformity is partly to blame for that.”

Voter turnout in the last four midterm general elections, when unaffiliated voters had the choice to participate in either major party’s primary election, was 42.91% in 2022, 47.93% in 2018, 37.8% in 2014 when the number of participating voters, 462,864, was nearly the same as in 2026, and 44% in 2010.

“For the 2022 general, there were 1,156,147 registered voters," Warner said. "Despite having 54,150 more registered voters in 2026 than in 2022, 17,872 of which were added after the 2026 primary, turnout was still the lowest we’ve seen since 2014.”

Warner said it is believed that the majority of instances where unaffiliated voters cast Republican ballots during the primary election was because of poll worker confusion, voter confusion and human error. The majority of errors can be avoided if the political party primary elections are uniformly administered, he said.

“The Republican Party has an opportunity to swiftly take-up this issue for the betterment of our state. Alternatively, the Legislature has the authority to fix this issue statutorily and bring the state back in line with the 42 other states with uniform standards," Warner said. "Whatever the avenue, we must have uniformity. The integrity of West Virginia’s elections depends on it.”

An emailed request for a comment to the chairman of the Republican Party, Josh Holstein, was not returned.

Mike Pushkin, chairman of the Democratic Party, said Warner was trying to "rescue his own party from the consequences of a decision Republicans freely made" to exclude unaffiliated independent voters in their primary elections.

"Now, rather than allowing Republicans to live with the consequences of that decision, Warner is raising the specter of a legislative "solution" that could force Democrats to close their primaries as well, denying independent voters a voice in choosing Democratic nominees," Pushkin said.

The Democrats believe independent voters should have a voice in their elections, Pushkin said. Republicans made a different choice, their prerogative, but shouldn't be allowed to impose that choice on everyone else through legislative action, he said.

"If Secretary Warner is genuinely concerned about election integrity and restoring public trust in our elections, he should turn his attention to the issue of partisan gerrymandering, which unfairly dilutes the voices of voters across West Virginia to unfairly advantage his party," Pushkin said. "Instead of trying to dictate how political parties conduct their primaries, he should be advocating for fair legislative districts that allow voters to choose their representatives, rather than allowing politicians to choose their voters."

Starting at /week.