Breaking News
Local News

Federal grand jury indicts State Auditor Hunt in property ‘scheme’ probe

By Steven Allen Adams 8 min read
U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia Moore Capito, joined by assistant U.S. attorneys, FBI agents and investigators with the West Virginia Legislature's Commission on Special Investigations, briefs reporters Monday afternoon on the indictment of State Auditor Mark Hunt and other employees of the State Auditor's Office. (Photo by Steven Allen Adams)

CHARLESTON - State Auditor Mark Hunt and several members of his staff are facing multiple charges in what U.S. Attorney Moore Capito called a "scheme" to steal properties on behalf of a friend.

In a press release Monday afternoon, Capito - the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia - said Hunt, Charleston attorney Robert Johns and three other employees of the State Auditor's Office were indicted by a federal grand jury on multiple counts.

"This is a somber day for West Virginia, but a clear message we are sending to all West Virginians: that our public institutions deserve respect and will be treated with respect, because West Virginians deserve that," Capito said in a press conference Monday afternoon at the Robert C. Byrd Federal Courthouse in downtown Charleston.

Hunt, Johns, Deputy Chief of Staff David Keith Cole and General Counsel Frederick Scott Caudill each face nine counts of theft of property, while Caudill and Cole each face an additional count of making materially false statements to federal investigators. Hunt, Cole and another employee of the State Auditor's Office, Marie Ann Hoffman, were also indicted on charges of bank fraud.

The charges stem from a federal investigation that began last year into actions taken by Hunt and certain staff regarding nine delinquent property tax deeds signed personally by Hunt on behalf of a real estate company owned by Johns’ wife.

Documents obtained last week through a Freedom of Information Act request from the State Auditor's Office and previously reported by West Virginia Watch show Hunt signed the deeds last year on behalf of MAPA Inc., a real estate company owned by Patricia Johns. Robert Johns is a friend and business associate of Hunt who also worked briefly last year as a special counsel in the State Auditor’s Office according to federal investigators.

All nine deeds were executed past the 120-day statutory window mandated by West Virginia code and without a circuit court order. The deeds are also supposed to be signed by the deputy commissioner of delinquent and nonentered lands and not by the auditor, but only these nine deeds have been signed by Hunt personally. One of the nine transferred properties Patricia Johns' MAPA purchased had been owned by NAJ LLC, an entity listing Robert L. Johns as a member and organizer, also in violation of state code.

According to the indictments, State Auditor’s Office staff within the Land Division advised Hunt that the property deeds could not be legally executed on behalf of Johns due to required payments by MAPA not being made and the 120-day statutory deadline being missed. But Hunt ignored this advice, signing the deeds over to MAPA anyway, aided and abetted by Caudill and Cole, court documents say.

"Career employees of the Auditor’s Office had determined that the purchaser failed to meet the requirements under West Virginia law and was not entitled to receive those deeds," Capito said. "However, according to the indictment, Mr. Hunt overruled those employees and personally signed and issued all nine of those deeds."

Capito said these actions amounted to a theft of property from the original landowners. The indictment alleges that both Caudill and Cole lied to FBI agents. Caudill is accused of asking State Auditor’s Office employees "who will be the whistleblower" regarding the nine deeds.

The indictment of Hoffman accuses her of carrying out a timecard scheme before May 5, 2025, and Sept. 29 of this year, aided and abetted by Cole and Hoffman. According to the indictment, Hoffman would leave work on Friday afternoons to perform private work for Hunt’s law practice while on state time, defrauding taxpayers, with all three working frequently together at the law firm during state work hours.

"The rules governing public office are not optional. They do not change based on who you know, who your friends are or what position you hold," Capito said. "The integrity of public institutions depends on public officials faithfully carrying out their responsibilities. As alleged, the state auditor violated that trust."

A request for comment from the State Auditor’s Office was not returned, though Hunt posted on social media that "I am innocent of these charges. This indictment is an insult to the principles on which this country was founded. I am presumed innocent and will vigorously defend myself against these charges."

Johns has not commented publicly about the case and a request for comment last week regarding the deeds went unreturned. West Virginia Watch reported Saturday that a used car dealership started by Hunt months prior to taking office as state auditor on property owned by Johns' NAJ company recently shut down.

The investigation involved the FBI and the West Virginia Legislature’s Commission on Special Investigations. Capito said that no arrest warrants would be issued, with those indicted self-reporting to federal authorities.

"Folks in West Virginia have every right to expect the people entrusted with their tax dollars and the public institutions follow that law," Capito said. "And when there is evidence that public officials have abused that trust, it is our responsibility to investigate, and we’re warranted to prosecute.

Calls for Hunt’s resignation came rolling in Monday afternoon from State Treasurer Larry Pack and the West Virginia Democratic and Republican parties.

"The State Auditor's job is to protect the people's money and the people's property," said Del. Josh Holstein, R-Boone, chairman of the West Virginia Republican Party. "These charges say Mark Hunt used the power of that office to take property from West Virginia families. That is a betrayal of the public trust, and our Party will not defend nor tolerate it. Mark Hunt should resign today and let the justice system play out without a cloud hanging over the Auditor's office."

Pack had previously been critical of Hunt after it was revealed earlier this year that the auditor’s office had briefly hired state Sen. Jay Taylor, R-Taylor, despite a state constitutional prohibition against lawmakers working for state government agencies and over objections raised by Attorney General J.B. McCuskey.

"Everyone is presumed innocent until proven guilty. Even so, these are grave charges that demand serious attention," Pack said. "West Virginians deserve a government that is fully transparent, accountable and works for the betterment of our state. State Auditor Mark Hunt should resign immediately so these charges do not overshadow our efforts to make West Virginia a better place to live, work and raise a family. The people of the Mountain State deserve better, especially from their elected officials."

Last week, the Democratic caucuses in the House of Delegates and state Senate wrote a letter to House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, and Senate President Randy Smith, R-Preston, asking them to seek an advisory opinion from the Attorney General’s Office regarding the legality of Hunt’s actions regarding the nine delinquent property tax deeds.

"The West Virginia State Auditor's job is to investigate waste, fraud and abuse across state agencies - not to be the creator of waste, fraud and abuse," said Del. Mike Pushkin, D-Kanawha, chairman of the West Virginia Democratic Party. "For Mark Hunt to remain in office under these circumstances would be like leaving the fox in charge of the henhouse. Mark Hunt, David Cole, Frederic Caudill, Marie Ann Hoffmann and Robert Johns should resign their public positions immediately."

In his own statement, Hanshaw also called on Hunt to resign or face the possibility of impeachment proceedings in the House. If impeachment articles are adopted, the Senate would determine whether to convict Hunt and remove him from office.

"These serious allegations cast a long shadow over the Office of the State Auditor and its role of maintaining the integrity of other state and local officials," Hanshaw said. "Every American is entitled to due process and the presumption of innocence in every criminal proceeding, but the public is entitled to leadership from the officers it elects; Mountaineers should always be free from the sort of taint these indictments create.

"Auditor Hunt should immediately resign from his office," Hanshaw continued. "If he resolves to do otherwise, the House of Delegates will take swift action in January to restore integrity to the Office of the West Virginia State Auditor."

"I remain focused on the work of the Auditor’s Office and will continue to serve the people of West Virginia while this matter is resolved in court," Hunt said Monday in his social media statement.

The last impeachment of a member of the Board of Public Works by the Legislature was 1988 of State Treasurer A. James Manchin, resigning before his Senate impeachment trial. In 2018, the House impeached the entire West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals as a result of findings of misspending, mismanagement of the court and personal use of state property by one or all of the remaining justices on the court at that time.

Former Justice Menis Ketchum resigned before the impeachment investigation, later pleading guilty to a federal charge of wire fraud. Former Justice Robin Davis resigned rather than face an impeachment trial. Former Justice Allen Loughry resigned from the court in November 2018 after being convicted of 11 federal crimes, including wire fraud and lying to federal investigators.

Former Justice Beth Walker was acquitted of her lone article of impeachment by the Senate. Former Justice Margaret Workman was slated to face an impeachment trial to remove her from office, but she filed suit against the Senate to halt her trial, arguing that the House did not follow the procedures they adopted for impeachment in June 2018.

Starting at /week.