Breaking News
Community News

Democrats’ legal bid fails to claim W.Va. House seat vacated following de Soto’s home confinement

By Steven Allen Adams 5 min read
Justice Charles Trump and Senior Status Justice Beth Walker, seen here on Sept. 22 during oral arguments, joined the majority of justices in ruling Friday that the West Virginia Democratic Party had no standing to bring a lawsuit asking the court to either seat former delegate-elect Joseph de Soto or force the appointment of a Democrat to the seat. (Photo Courtesy/WV Supreme Court of Appeals)

CHARLESTON - An attempt by the West Virginia Democratic Party to force the appointment of a Democrat to succeed former Republican-turned Democrat delegate-elect Joseph de Soto after he his seat was declared vacant following alleged threats made to lawmakers was too late.

In a signed opinion issued Friday, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals rejected a petition for a writ of mandamus brought by the state Democratic Party seeking to challenge de Soto's legislative vacancy and the process that resulted in the appointment of outgoing Del. Ian Masters, R-Berkeley, last year.

De Soto won election to the 91st District seat in the November 2024 general election as a Republican and switched parties just prior to being arrested in December 2024 and charged with making terroristic threats to several GOP House members following a caucus meeting.

De Soto was arrested after a West Virginia State Police investigation into threats he allegedly made to another person regarding several lawmakers stemming from a closed-door meeting of the House Republican caucus on Dec. 8, 2024, where members agreed to move forward with his expulsion over allegedly false claims about his military service.

The state Constitution requires legislators to take their oath of office within the House Chamber, something de Soto is unable to do due to being on home confinement and with two protective orders from House members barring him from the State Capitol Building until 10 days following the conclusion of the 2025 regular legislative session.

During a January 2025 organizational session prior to the start of the 60-day regular session in February of that year, the House adopted House Resolution 4, declaring de Soto's 91st District seat vacant. Ian Masters, a Gerrardstown attorney, was appointed by Morrisey to the seat after the Berkeley County Republican Executive Committee submitted three names to the governor for consideration.

The Democratic Party filed a lawsuit against House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, and Gov. Patrick Morrisey last year on behalf of Berkeley County resident and Democratic voter Stephen Willingham, asking the court to force the appointment of a Democratic replacement for de Soto or force Hanshaw to seat de Soto.

In the unanimous decision, the justices determined that the Democratic Party and Willingham lacked standing because the court could not provide effective redress, noting that another representative - Masters – already held the disputed seat and the individual in question - de Soto - was not a party to the lawsuit and was bound by criminal bail restrictions preventing him from serving.

"Respondents cannot force Mr. de Soto to appear to take the oath, and Petitioners have not demonstrated that Mr. de Soto is willing or able to take the oath, especially considering his ongoing criminal proceedings," wrote Chief Justice C. Haley Bunn. "... Their own delay in properly bringing this proceeding ... until after the vacancy had been filled, as well as their failure to include Mr. de Soto as a party or at least demonstrate that Mr. de Soto was able and willing to be seated, mean that Speaker Hanshaw cannot be compelled to provide the relief Petitioners seek from him."

Justice Bill Flanigan, who was a member of the House of Delegates and participated in the vote on House Resolution 4 last year, recused himself and was replaced on the bench by former Justice Beth Walker.

While the decision of the court was unanimous, both Walker and Justice Charles Trump wrote their own opinion, arguing that the separation of powers between the three branches of government prevented the high court from weighing in at all, citing Holmes v. Clawges. Trump also raised concerns about a 2018 decision by the state Supreme Court that halted the impeachment process for former justice Margaret Workman.

"[U]nder [West Virginia's] Separation of Powers doctrine" the 'courts have no authority – by mandamus, prohibition, contempt or otherwise – to interfere with the proceedings of either house of the Legislature,'" Trump and Walker wrote. "In 2018, this Court disapproved of the Holmes holding when it unconstitutionally enjoined a legislative impeachment proceeding against one of the Court's own justices."

"Reinstating the constitutionally 'sound' Holmes holding would allow this Court to decide

the matter before us narrowly and definitively, on the basis that this Court lacks the constitutional authority to issue any form of coercive relief against the Legislature and, therefore, cannot redress the petitioners' claimed injuries as they request," Trump and Walker continued.

In a separate concurring opinion, Justice William Wooton sided with his fellow justices but criticized the legal maneuvering of the state Attorney General's Office on behalf of Morrisey and Hanshaw that delayed consideration of the case by the Supreme Court until oral arguments at the end of September. He also criticized the House for not holding an expulsion vote to remove de Soto, which requires a two-thirds vote.

"As a member of this Court, I have a disturbing unease about the majority's decision, a profound feeling that in the path this Court has followed to get to this point in the history of this case we have failed in our duty to ensure justice was done for the people of this State," Wooton wrote. "Instead, by engaging in gamesmanship with the Legislature, the Republican majority was increased by one delegate. My concern is that those elected representatives vested with the responsibility to establish procedures for filling vacancies in the Legislature, and the representative charged with appointing new members to the Legislature in case of a vacancy, sacrificed the law and the Constitution to achieve a meaningless numerical gain."

De Soto remains on home confinement. A grand jury in Berkeley County charged him earlier this year with unlicensed practice of medicine, misrepresentation of authorization to practice medicine, false indication or inducement of authorization to practice medicine, misrepresentation of past military status or military award, threats of terrorist acts and grossly inaccurate campaign finance statement.

Masters declined to seek election to the 91st House District seat. Republican Chris Clagett defeated Democratic opponent David Michaels for the seat after the Nov. 3 general election.

Starting at /week.